1958 Penny Error List with Pictures & Value
Welcome to the comprehensive 1958 Penny error list, your complete guide to identifying valuable errors on 1958 Lincoln wheat pennies. From doubled dies to off-center strikes, discover which errors make your 1958 penny worth keeping. Learn more about 1958 Penny value and start your coin collecting journey today.
1958 Penny Doubled Die Obverse Error
The 1958 doubled die obverse (DDO) error displays clear doubling on the front of the coin, most notably visible on the lettering and date. This error occurs when the die receives multiple impressions during the hubbing process, creating a distinct doubled image.
Value Range
$50 to $500+ depending on the strength of doubling and condition. Strong, well-defined examples in uncirculated condition command premium prices.
Identification Tips
- Examine LIBERTY closely for doubled letters, especially the L and B
- Check the date 1958 for doubled digits
- Look at IN GOD WE TRUST for separation between letters
- Use at least 10x magnification for accurate identification
- True doubling shows clear separation, not just thickness or wear
1958 Penny Doubled Die Reverse Error
The doubled die reverse (DDR) error shows doubling on the back of the coin, typically visible on ONE CENT, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, or the wheat stalks. These varieties are generally scarcer than obverse doubled dies.
Value Range
$50 to $200 depending on doubling strength and grade. Clear examples with strong separation are most desirable to collectors.
Identification Tips
- Inspect ONE CENT for doubled letters, especially the E and N
- Check UNITED STATES OF AMERICA for letter separation
- Examine wheat stalks for doubled lines
- Compare to known DDR varieties for confirmation
- Strong magnification reveals subtle doubling details
1958 Penny Repunched Date Error
Repunched date (RPD) errors occur when the date is punched into the die multiple times in slightly different positions, creating a shadow or doubling effect on the numbers. The 1958 penny has several documented RPD varieties.
Value Range
$10 to $75 based on the visibility of the repunching and overall coin condition. Strong, clear repunching in mint state grades brings higher premiums.
Identification Tips
- Focus on the date 1958 under magnification
- Look for extra thickness or notches on number edges
- The 8 and 5 most commonly show repunching
- Compare both mint marks (no mark and D) for varieties
- Check reference guides for known RPD positions
1958 Penny Off-Center Strike Error
Off-center strike errors happen when the planchet is not properly positioned in the collar during striking. The resulting coin shows partial design with a blank crescent area. The date must be visible for maximum value.
Value Range
$25 to $300 depending on the percentage off-center and date visibility. Dramatic off-center strikes (30-50%) with full dates are most valuable.
Identification Tips
- Measure the percentage of design missing
- Confirm the date 1958 is visible on the coin
- 10-25% off-center: moderate premiums
- 25-50% off-center: significant value increase
- Over 50% off-center: extreme rarity but date often missing
1958 Penny Broadstrike Error
Broadstrike errors occur when a penny is struck without the restraining collar, allowing the metal to spread beyond normal diameter. These coins have a larger circumference and lack the raised rim typical of normal strikes.
Value Range
$20 to $125 based on how dramatically oversized the coin is and overall condition. Extreme broadstrikes with significant diameter expansion are most sought after.
Identification Tips
- Measure the diameter - normal pennies are 19mm
- Check for missing or weak rim on both sides
- Design elements appear spread out and flatter
- Edge remains unstruck and smooth
- Coin may appear slightly bowl-shaped
How Much is 1958 Penny Error List Worth? Coin Identifier I Recommended
CoinValueChecker
CoinValueChecker is a comprehensive mobile application designed for coin collectors and enthusiasts to quickly identify and value their coins. The app features advanced image recognition technology that can identify coins from photos, including error varieties. Users can access detailed pricing information based on current market values, grade estimates, and condition assessments. The app includes a vast database of coin errors with high-resolution comparison images, making it ideal for authenticating 1958 penny errors like doubled dies, off-center strikes, and repunched dates. CoinValueChecker also offers a personal collection management system where users can track their coins, monitor value changes over time, and receive notifications about market trends. The app is particularly useful for beginners who need step-by-step guidance in identifying subtle error characteristics.
CoinKnow
CoinKnow is a specialized coin identification and educational app that combines artificial intelligence with expert numismatic knowledge. The app excels at providing detailed historical information, minting data, and error variety identification for coins from all eras. CoinKnow features an extensive library of 1958 penny errors with detailed descriptions, identification markers, and value ranges based on authenticated auction results. Users can photograph their coins and receive instant identification along with specific variety information, including die markers and attribution details. The app includes interactive learning modules that teach collectors how to spot errors, grade coins, and understand market dynamics. CoinKnow also maintains an active community forum where users can share discoveries, ask experts questions, and participate in discussions about rare varieties. The app is particularly valuable for intermediate to advanced collectors seeking detailed technical information and variety attribution.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most valuable 1958 penny error?
The most valuable 1958 penny error is the doubled die obverse (DDO), particularly strong examples showing clear doubling on LIBERTY and the date. High-grade specimens can be worth $100 to $500 or more. Use the CoinValueChecker App to get accurate pricing for your specific coin's condition and error severity.
How can I identify a 1958 doubled die penny?
Look for visible doubling on the obverse lettering, especially LIBERTY, IN GOD WE TRUST, and the date 1958. Use a magnifying glass or jeweler's loupe to examine the coin under good lighting. The CoinKnow App provides detailed identification guides with comparison images to help you spot genuine doubled die errors.
What is a 1958 BIE error penny?
A BIE error occurs when a die crack creates a vertical line between the letters B and I in LIBERTY, making it appear as if there's an extra letter. These are relatively common and typically worth $5 to $25 depending on condition. The CoinValueChecker App can help you determine if your BIE error has additional value based on crack severity.
Are 1958-D pennies with errors more valuable than Philadelphia mint errors?
Both 1958 and 1958-D pennies can have valuable errors, but rarity and error type matter more than mint mark. Some 1958-D errors are scarcer than their Philadelphia counterparts. Use the CoinKnow App to compare values across different mint marks and error varieties for accurate market pricing.
What is an off-center strike error on a 1958 penny?
An off-center strike occurs when the planchet is not properly aligned during striking, resulting in part of the design missing. The value depends on the percentage off-center and whether the date is visible. Off-center strikes showing 10-50% misalignment with visible dates can be worth $25 to $200. The CoinValueChecker App provides detailed valuations based on the specific off-center percentage.
How much is a 1958 repunched date penny worth?
Repunched date (RPD) errors on 1958 pennies typically range from $10 to $75 depending on the prominence of the repunching and overall condition. Strong, clearly visible repunched dates in uncirculated condition command premium prices. The CoinKnow App offers expert grading assistance to help you assess the strength of your repunched date variety.
What is a 1958 doubled die reverse penny?
A doubled die reverse (DDR) shows doubling on the reverse design elements, particularly visible on ONE CENT, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, or the wheat stalks. These are less common than obverse varieties and can be worth $50 to $150 in collectible grades. Use the CoinValueChecker App to identify and value specific DDR varieties.
Are broadstrike 1958 pennies valuable?
Broadstrike errors occur when a penny is struck without the restraining collar, resulting in a larger diameter and unstruck edge. These errors typically range from $20 to $100 depending on how dramatically oversized the coin is. The CoinKnow App can help you measure and evaluate your broadstrike error for accurate pricing.
What should I look for in a 1958 clipped planchet error?
Clipped planchet errors show a missing portion of the coin where the planchet was incorrectly cut from the metal strip. Look for smooth, curved clips (elliptical) or straight clips with visible blakesley effect. Values range from $15 to $100 based on clip size and type. The CoinValueChecker App includes visual guides to help identify different clipped planchet varieties.
Can I find 1958 penny errors in circulation today?
While rare, it is still possible to find 1958 penny errors in circulation, particularly in coin rolls from banks. BIE errors and minor die cracks are most commonly found, while major errors like doubled dies are extremely scarce. The CoinKnow App is perfect for quickly checking pennies you find to identify potential errors worth keeping.
Summary
The 1958 penny error list encompasses a fascinating range of valuable varieties that appeal to collectors of all levels. From dramatic doubled die errors worth hundreds of dollars to accessible broadstrike varieties, 1958 wheat pennies offer numerous opportunities for error hunters. The most valuable errors include doubled die obverses and strong off-center strikes with visible dates, while repunched dates, doubled die reverses, and broadstrikes represent excellent mid-range collectibles. Successful identification requires proper magnification, good lighting, and familiarity with genuine error characteristics. Whether you're searching pocket change or examining coin rolls, understanding these five major error types can help you discover valuable treasures hiding in plain sight. Careful examination, patience, and the right identification tools are essential for building a quality error coin collection focused on 1958 Lincoln cents.